Email Formats: HTML vs. Plain Text—Which Drives Better Results?

The long-running HTML vs. text email debate really boils down to one simple question: What are you trying to accomplish with this email? HTML gives you beautiful, branded visuals and lets you track just about everything, while plain text is all about maximizing deliverability and feeling personal. The right choice depends entirely on whether your goal is to dazzle with design or connect with a genuine, human touch.

This guide will walk you through the practical differences, show you step-by-step how to use each format effectively, and help you decide which one is right for your next campaign.

Grasping the Core Differences

Before diving into strategy, let's clarify what truly separates these two formats. Think of it like sending a handwritten letter versus a glossy postcard. A plain-text email is that letter—it’s direct, simple, and feels one-to-one. An HTML email is the postcard, full of images and colors designed to grab your eye instantly.

But this isn't just about looks. The format you choose directly impacts how your message is delivered, how subscribers perceive it, and how you measure its success. While HTML opens up a world of creative branding and in-depth analytics, it can also create headaches with deliverability and rendering on different email clients. On the flip side, plain text's simplicity is its greatest weapon, often leading to better inbox placement and a more authentic vibe.

A Quick Guide to Email Format Strengths

To make things easier, here’s a quick summary of how HTML and plain text stack up in the areas that matter most to marketers. Think of this table as a cheat sheet for the core trade-offs you’ll be making.

Feature	HTML Emails	Plain Text Emails
Design Flexibility	High (custom fonts, images, colors, layouts)	None (standard text only, no visual elements)
Tracking & Analytics	Robust (open rates, click maps, link tracking)	Limited (only link clicks can be tracked)
Deliverability	Can be flagged by spam filters due to heavy code	Excellent (lightweight and rarely triggers filters)
Perceived Authenticity	Often seen as a promotional or marketing message	Feels like a personal, one-to-one communication
Accessibility	Requires careful coding (alt text, etc.) to be accessible	Natively accessible to all users and screen readers

This isn't about one format being universally "better." It's about picking the right tool for the job.

Real-World Example: A promotional product launch needs the visual firepower of HTML to show off the goods. But a personal follow-up email to a new lead will land with more impact if it feels like it came straight from you—and that’s where the authenticity of plain text shines.

What’s interesting is that while HTML has been the default for years, we're seeing a strategic shift. In many cases, especially when the goal is to build relationships, plain text is winning. For instance, some studies show that plain text emails consistently beat HTML in cold outreach, boosting click-through rates by a surprising 30% to 42%. You can dig into these findings in Warmforge's research on email formats. This data drives home the point that you must match your format to your audience's expectations.

The Strategic Power of Plain Text Emails

In an inbox drowning in flashy graphics, sometimes the simplest message cuts through the noise the loudest. That's the secret weapon of plain-text emails—they're just text. No fancy formatting. They look and feel like a personal note sent directly from a colleague or a friend, not a faceless marketing machine.

This perceived authenticity is precisely where their power comes from. When someone opens a plain-text email, it feels like a genuine, one-on-one conversation. This minimalist style strips away all the corporate branding, building a sense of trust and direct connection that’s tough to replicate with a polished HTML design.

This directness is a huge differentiator in the ongoing email formats HTML vs text debate. You could say that while HTML emails shout, plain-text emails speak. That makes them an incredible tool for building real relationships.

Superior Deliverability and Accessibility

One of the biggest practical advantages of plain text is its rock-solid deliverability. Because these emails have no complex code, tracking pixels, or heavy images, they almost never trigger spam filters. Internet Service Providers (ISPs) view them as low-risk, which gives your message a much better shot at landing in the primary inbox instead of the promotions tab or, worse, the spam folder.

On top of that, plain-text emails are universally compatible. They look perfect on every single device and email client, from the newest iPhone to an old-school email reader. This guarantees a consistent, frustration-free experience for every subscriber.

Here’s what that means for you:

• Near-Perfect Rendering: Your message will look exactly as you intended, everywhere. No more worrying about broken images or messed-up layouts.
• Enhanced Accessibility: Plain text is naturally accessible for users with disabilities who rely on screen readers, making your message inclusive.
• Faster Loading Times: With zero images or scripts to load, the email appears instantly—a game-changer for anyone on a slow internet connection.

For marketers who are serious about building genuine connections, the high deliverability and personal feel of plain text are invaluable. It’s a format built on trust, not just clicks.

Step-by-Step: Crafting an Effective Plain-Text Message

Writing a powerful plain-text email is all about clear, compelling communication. Your message has to be concise and actionable without any help from colorful buttons or images.

Here’s a simple, step-by-step approach that works in any email platform:

1. Write a Clear, Personal Subject Line: Ditch the overly promotional language that screams "marketing blast." If you want to dive deeper, our guide to improve email open rates has some killer strategies.
2. Focus on a Single Goal: What’s the one thing you want the reader to do? Make that action the absolute centerpiece of your message.
3. Use White Space to Improve Readability: Since you can't rely on formatting, break your text into very short paragraphs—just 1-3 sentences each. This makes the email scannable and easy to digest.
4. Craft a Clear Call-to-Action (CTA): Your CTA will be a link. Make sure the link text is descriptive and place the full URL on its own line so it’s impossible to miss.

For example:

To learn more, check out the full guide here:
https://emailgum.com/your-guide-link

This simple, focused approach respects your reader's time and attention. It’s incredibly effective for personal outreach, follow-up sequences, and any message where building trust is the main goal.

Engaging Audiences with HTML Emails

If plain-text emails are the handwritten notes of the email world, HTML emails are the glossy, full-color brochures. HTML (Hypertext Markup Language) is the same code that builds websites. In an email, it lets you create a message that pops with images, custom fonts, brand colors, and clickable buttons. It’s how a basic message becomes a rich, interactive brand experience.

This visual-first approach is central to modern marketing. Every promotional email from an e-commerce brand showing off new products, or a newsletter with a sleek, organized layout, is an HTML email. Their purpose is to tell a compelling visual story that nudges you to take action.

The strategic upside is huge. HTML gives you the control to guide your reader’s eye, reinforce your brand identity, and make it ridiculously easy for them to click, buy, or sign up. This is a massive differentiator in the email formats HTML vs text debate—HTML is built from the ground up for engagement and conversion.

Driving Sales and Reinforcing Brand Identity

One of the biggest wins for HTML emails is the power to create crystal-clear, visually distinct calls-to-action (CTAs). A bright, clickable "Shop Now" button is far more persuasive than a simple blue hyperlink. That single visual cue can skyrocket click-through rates, which has a direct impact on sales and sign-ups.

On top of that, HTML is your best friend for brand consistency. You can embed your company's logo, stick to your exact color palette, and use custom fonts to make your emails instantly recognizable. This consistency builds brand recall and paints a professional, trustworthy picture every time you hit send. If you want to go deeper, our guide on email design best practices is packed with actionable advice.

And despite what some might say about deliverability, well-designed HTML emails perform incredibly well. Email open rates hit a strong 26.6% last year, an impressive figure largely driven by smart HTML campaigns that nailed their subject lines, mobile design, and personalization.

Step-by-Step: Creating a Simple and Effective HTML Email

You don't need to be a coding wizard to create a beautiful HTML email. Most modern email service providers (ESPs) like Mailchimp or ConvertKit have drag-and-drop editors that do all the heavy lifting for you.

Here’s a quick guide to building a mobile-responsive HTML email that works:

• Step 1: Pick a Single-Column Layout: This is your safest bet. It guarantees your email will look sharp on both large desktop screens and small mobile ones, preventing awkward formatting issues.
• Step 2: Add Your Logo: Place it right at the top. This immediately tells subscribers who the email is from.
• Step 3: Use a Hero Image: Choose one high-impact image that summarizes the core message of your email. This is your visual hook—make it count.
• Step 4: Write Concise Copy: Keep your text short and scannable. Use clear headings and brief paragraphs to get your point across quickly.
• Step 5: Drop in a Clear CTA Button: Use a button with a color that stands out and text that demands action (e.g., "Get 20% Off," "Read the Full Story"). Make sure it's big enough to be easily tapped on a phone.

Common Pitfall to Avoid: Always test your HTML email across different clients like Gmail, Outlook, and Apple Mail before sending. Rendering issues are a constant headache. What looks perfect in your editor might be a broken mess in someone's inbox. Use testing tools like Litmus or Email on Acid to preview your campaign before you launch.

Comparing Key Performance Factors

Choosing between HTML and plain text goes far beyond looks; it's a strategic decision that directly impacts your campaign performance. To get to the heart of the email formats HTML vs text debate, we need to dig into how each one stacks up against the metrics that actually matter.

We'll break this down across four critical areas: deliverability, engagement, accessibility, and tracking. Understanding these trade-offs will give you the confidence to pick the right format for any situation.

Deliverability: How Spam Filters See Your Emails

The first, and most important, hurdle for any email is getting into the inbox. This is where plain text has a massive, built-in advantage.

Because plain-text emails contain no code, scripts, or heavy images, they’re incredibly lightweight and come across as inherently trustworthy to spam filters and Internet Service Providers (ISPs). They look and feel like a personal, one-to-one message, which is a format that rarely gets flagged.

HTML emails, on the other hand, get a much closer look. They can contain complex code, multiple images, and tracking pixels—all things spammers have abused in the past. This doesn't mean your HTML email is doomed, but it does mean it carries a higher risk if it isn't coded perfectly.

A few things that can hurt your HTML email deliverability:

• Excessive Code: Bloated or messy HTML can be a red flag for spam filters.
• Poor Image-to-Text Ratio: An email that's all image and no text looks suspicious.
• Suspicious Links: Using sketchy link shorteners or linking to untrustworthy domains will damage your sender reputation.

The bottom line is that a poorly built HTML email is far more likely to trigger a spam filter than any plain-text email. When inbox placement is your number one priority, plain text is the safer bet. For a deeper dive, check out our guide on how to improve email deliverability for more advanced strategies.

Engagement: Opens, Clicks, and Replies

This is where the comparison gets more interesting. HTML emails are designed from the ground up to drive specific actions, usually with visually striking calls-to-action (CTAs). A bright, clickable button will almost always get more clicks than a simple blue hyperlink. That visual direction is precisely why HTML dominates for e-commerce promotions, newsletters, and big announcements.

However, plain text often takes the lead on open and reply rates, especially in B2B or any campaign focused on building relationships. Because these emails feel so personal, recipients are often more likely to open them and respond as if they just got a direct message from a colleague. This creates a conversational feel that a polished, branded HTML email can struggle to replicate.

Let's break it down by situation:

• For Click-Throughs: HTML wins, hands down. Its visual CTAs are built to drive traffic to landing pages, products, or blog posts.
• For Open Rates: Plain text can sometimes pull ahead, thanks to better deliverability and subject lines that feel more personal.
• For Replies: Plain text is the undisputed champion. Its simple, conversational nature actively invites a direct response.

Accessibility: Making Sure Everyone Can Read Your Message

Accessibility isn't just a nice-to-have; it's a must. You need to ensure that all your subscribers, including those with disabilities who use screen readers, can understand your content.

On this front, plain text is the clear winner by default. It’s universally accessible and requires zero extra work.

HTML emails, conversely, require a conscious effort to be made accessible. To do it right, you have to:

• Use proper semantic HTML (headings, paragraphs, lists).
• Add descriptive alt text to every image so screen readers can explain what's there.
• Ensure there's enough color contrast between your text and background.
• Code buttons so they're recognized as interactive elements.

If you skip these steps, your beautifully designed HTML email can become a jumbled, indecipherable mess for a screen reader, effectively shutting out part of your audience.

Tracking Capabilities: Measuring What Works

Finally, let's talk about data. The power to track your campaign's performance is what lets you improve over time, and this is where HTML has a massive technological advantage.

HTML emails can measure open rates by embedding a tiny, invisible tracking pixel (usually a 1x1 image). When a subscriber's email client loads the images in the email, it loads that pixel from your server, and—voilà—you've registered an "open."

Beyond that, every link in an HTML email can be uniquely tagged. This allows for incredibly detailed click-through rate tracking. You can see not just that someone clicked, but exactly which link they clicked. Plain-text emails can't track opens at all and can only track clicks if you run your links through a tracking redirect service, giving you a much less complete picture of engagement.

Matching the Format to Your Campaign Goal

Picking between HTML and plain text isn't about which one is "better." It's about choosing the right tool for the job. The best email strategies always match the format to the campaign's goal, the audience's expectations, and the action you want them to take.

If your main goal is to build trust, share crucial information, or create a personal connection, plain text is your best friend. Its simple, one-on-one feel is perfect for campaigns where authenticity is everything.

On the other hand, when you need to drive sales, show off a visual product, or create a memorable brand experience, HTML is the clear winner. Its design capabilities are essential for grabbing attention and steering users toward a conversion.

When to Use Plain Text Emails

Plain text shines in situations that feel like personal communication. This format cuts through the clutter of a flashy inbox because it reads less like a marketing blast and more like a direct message from an actual person.

Think of plain text as your go-to for:

• Personal Outreach and Sales Follow-ups: A simple, text-based email feels more genuine and is far more likely to get a reply.
• Onboarding Sequences: Welcome emails and early onboarding messages build trust when they feel personal and conversational, forging a strong user relationship from the start.
• Transactional Emails: For critical messages like password resets or shipping confirmations, clarity and deliverability are non-negotiable. Plain text ensures the message gets there fast and is easy to understand.

When to Use HTML Emails

For any campaign that leans on visual appeal and strong branding to get people to engage, HTML is the only way to go. For example, if you're a consultant figuring out your campaign goals, the choice between HTML and plain text becomes a core part of that strategy. You can explore various strategies for client acquisition through newsletters and see just how much the format can influence conversions.

HTML emails are the perfect fit for:

• E-commerce Promotions: You simply can't showcase products with high-quality images, embed "Buy Now" buttons, or display eye-catching sales banners without HTML.
• Newsletters and Content Roundups: Organizing a mix of content with clear headings, images, and distinct sections makes your newsletter scannable and much more engaging.
• Event Invitations and Announcements: Driving registrations or building hype requires strong visual branding and bold calls-to-action that only HTML can deliver.

This decision tree helps visualize the key questions—your goal, audience, and tracking needs—that should guide your choice.

The flowchart drives home the point that your campaign objective is the most important place to start when deciding between the powerful visual engagement of HTML and the trusted simplicity of plain text.

Actionable Takeaway: Match the format to the message. Use HTML to showcase and sell; use plain text to connect and converse.

Ultimately, the smartest marketers use both. The hybrid approach of sending multipart messages—which bundle both HTML and plain-text versions together—is now an industry best practice. This method guarantees maximum deliverability and a great user experience by letting the email client automatically display the best format for each recipient.

How to Implement the Best of Both Worlds

That constant debate over HTML vs text email formats? It has a surprisingly simple solution: you don’t have to choose. The modern standard is a hybrid approach that delivers the best of both worlds in a single send.

This method is called multipart MIME (Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions). The name might sound technical, but the concept is simple. It's a way to bundle both your beautiful HTML email and a clean plain-text version into one single package.

When this multipart email lands in an inbox, the subscriber’s email client (like Gmail, Outlook, or Apple Mail) automatically checks which format it can display best and shows that version. It’s the ultimate fallback strategy, built right into the email itself.

The Power of Automatic Fallback

The genius of multipart MIME is that it puts the user’s experience first without you having to lift a finger. It solves many of the core dilemmas that make marketers hesitate when picking a format.

Here’s how it plays out in different scenarios:

• Modern Email Clients: Most subscribers using up-to-date clients will see your rich HTML version, just as you designed it.
• High-Security Settings: For users with security settings that block HTML or images, the plain-text version is automatically shown. Your message still gets through.
• Smartwatches and Niche Devices: Wearables and other gadgets with limited displays will default to the clean, easy-to-read plain-text format.
• Accessibility Needs: Screen readers can easily process the plain-text version, making your content accessible to subscribers with visual impairments.

By sending a multipart email, you’re not just sending two versions; you’re empowering every email client to make the best choice for its user. This maximizes both deliverability and accessibility.

How to Enable Multipart Emails: A Step-by-Step Guide

Here's the best part: turning this on is incredibly easy. Nearly all modern email marketing platforms like Mailchimp, ConvertKit, and HubSpot automatically create a plain-text version for you whenever you build an HTML campaign. You just need to make sure it's polished.

Here’s a general guide that works for most platforms:

1. Step 1: Design Your HTML Email: Build your email in your ESP’s editor exactly as you normally would.
2. Step 2: Locate the Plain-Text Option: Before sending, look for a setting related to the plain-text version. You might find it under "Advanced Options" or in a pre-send checklist.
3. Step 3: Generate and Review: Most ESPs have a button like "Auto-generate plain text" or "Copy from HTML." Click it. The platform will strip out all the code and create a text-only draft.
4. Step 4: Clean It Up (Crucial Step): The auto-generated text is often messy. Take a minute to remove extra line breaks, tidy up link formatting, and ensure it’s scannable and easy to read.
5. Step 5: Send with Confidence: Once you’ve reviewed both versions, you’re ready to send. Your ESP will handle bundling them into a multipart MIME email.

So, What’s the Final Verdict?

After breaking down email formats html vs text, one thing is crystal clear: this isn't about picking a winner. It's about making a strategic choice based on your goals.

Plain text is your go-to for building genuine connections and nailing deliverability. On the flip side, HTML is the powerhouse for visual branding, deep analytics, and driving direct actions like sales or sign-ups. For most campaigns today, the smartest strategy is to simply use both.

Summary and Recommended Next Step

The modern best practice is to send a single email that contains both formats using multipart MIME. This lets the subscriber's email client automatically display the best version for their device, guaranteeing a clean, readable message for everyone. It gives you the branding and tracking power of HTML while keeping the universal reach and rock-solid deliverability of plain text.

Your Recommended Next Step: Run an A/B test. For your next campaign, send the standard multipart (HTML + text) version to one half of your audience segment, and a plain-text-only version to the other half. Compare the open, click-through, and reply rates. Let your audience's data tell you what truly works for them. As you continue to refine your strategy, master email communication best practices to ensure every message hits the mark.

---

Ready to level up your entire email marketing strategy? At EmailGum, we create in-depth guides and actionable advice to help you get real results. Explore our resources today and start building campaigns that actually convert.